A veteran Indianapolis Colts player has voiced deep frustration with the state of the organization, highlighting a perceived lack of direction and cohesion within the team. Speaking anonymously to Zak Keefer and James Boyd of The Athletic, the player didn’t hold back in criticizing the franchise’s struggles.
“There’s no vision,” the player said. “From the top down – from the front office, to the coaches, to the players – no one is ever on the same page. Every year at the end, we’re sitting here losing.”
The Colts’ 45-33 loss to the New York Giants, who entered the game with the league’s worst record, encapsulated their disappointing 2024 season. The defeat dropped Indianapolis to 7-9 and officially eliminated them from playoff contention for the fourth consecutive year.
The Colts’ ongoing struggles have cast doubt on the direction of the franchise. Head coach Shane Steichen, hired in 2023 after owner Jim Irsay fired Frank Reich, has compiled a 16-17 record heading into the final game of the season. Despite Steichen’s offensive pedigree, the team has failed to establish a consistent identity.
“If you look at the best teams in the league, they all have a vision, and they commit to it,” the anonymous player continued. “The Chiefs keep winning because they have a vision. The Lions turned things around because they have a vision. Here, it feels like we’re just spinning in circles.”
One controversial decision this season was Steichen’s October benching of rookie quarterback Anthony Richardson in favor of veteran Joe Flacco. Richardson, who had shown flashes of potential with a 3-3 record in six starts, was pulled after throwing five touchdowns and seven interceptions over that span. Steichen justified the move by claiming Flacco gave the team a better chance to win.
However, the gamble backfired as Flacco went 0-2 as a starter, throwing two touchdowns against four interceptions. Richardson eventually returned to the starting lineup, posting a 3-2 record before injuries sidelined him for the Week 17 matchup against the Giants.
RELATED: Pat McAfee Unleashes Blistering Criticism of Colts in Viral Social Media Rant
The offensive struggles have been evident throughout the season. After ranking 11th in points per game last year, the Colts’ offense has regressed to 23rd in EPA/play and 26th in offensive success rate through 16 games. While Steichen was expected to elevate the team’s offensive production, the results have fallen short of expectations.
The defense has fared no better under retained defensive coordinator Gus Bradley. Over the past two seasons, the Colts have ranked 21st in EPA/play and this year sit 27th in points allowed per game. The defensive unit’s inconsistency has further compounded the team’s woes.
With one game remaining against the division-leading Jacksonville Jaguars, the Colts are left to ponder the direction of the franchise. Ownership, coaching, and player alignment will be critical if the team hopes to escape the cycle of mediocrity that has defined recent years.
For now, the sentiment expressed by the veteran player reflects a deeper issue: a lack of shared vision and commitment within the organization. Whether the Colts can rectify these problems remains uncertain, but change will be necessary if they hope to return to playoff contention.
