Stephen A. Smith, the prominent lead analyst of First Take, recently sat down with NFL legend Tom Brady on The Stephen A. Smith Show to discuss the evolving challenges facing rookie quarterbacks in today’s NFL. The conversation, which has garnered significant attention, delves into the pressures and expectations placed on young QBs as they transition from college to the pros.
Smith, who recently signed a new deal with his network, allowing him to expand his role, shared a clip from the interview on social media, captioning it, “@TomBrady on the tragedy that is being forced on rookie QBs in today’s NFL.” In the clip, Brady offered his insights into the stark differences between how quarterbacks were developed during his era and how they are thrust into starting roles almost immediately in the current landscape.
Brady began by contrasting today’s college football environment with the one he experienced during his time at the University of Michigan. “There used to be college programs, now there are college teams,” Brady said, emphasizing the shift from a holistic developmental approach to a more playbook-oriented focus. “You’re no longer learning a program, you’re learning a playbook.”
Reflecting on his own journey, Brady recounted his five years at Michigan, where he gradually progressed from being the seventh quarterback on the depth chart to eventually earning the starting role. During this time, he learned essential skills such as drop-back passing, reading defenses, and understanding coverages—skills that were crucial to his development. “I had to learn from being the seventh quarterback on the depth chart to moving up to third, to ultimately being a starter,” Brady explained.
After college, Brady was further developed by Coach Bill Belichick and the New England Patriots’ offensive staff. He didn’t start in his first year, and that, according to Brady, was vital to his long-term success. “That was development,” he noted. “Then I went to New England and I was developed by Coach Belichick and the offensive staff there. I didn’t start my first year; I think it’s just a tragedy that we’re forcing these rookies to play early.”
RELATED: Drew Bledsoe Continues to Throw Shade at Tom Brady Ahead of His Fox Debut: ‘Squeaky-Ass Voice’
Brady argued that the premature thrusting of rookies into starting roles is a result of a game that has been “dumbed down,” leaving little room for the deep learning and development that once defined the sport. He lamented how the pressure to perform immediately discourages coaches from delving into complex strategies, as they feel their players don’t have the time to master them. “I think what happens is it discourages the coaches from going to deep levels,” Brady said. “Because they realize the players don’t have the opportunity to go to a deep level, so they’re just going to teach them where they’re at.”
The discussion quickly sparked reactions from fans, many of whom praised Brady for his candid assessment. “The GOAT giving a GOAT speech,” one fan commented. Another agreed with Brady’s critique, saying, “Being forced into terrible situations, I agree.” A third fan found Brady’s insights “absolutely incredible.”
However, not everyone was on board with Brady’s perspective. Some fans disagreed with the notion that the game has been simplified or that all rookie quarterbacks need to sit before starting. “I actually disagree with Brady here, the game isn’t being dumbed down, it just isn’t as run and defense-heavy as it used to be,” one fan argued. Another added, “Not every QB needs or should sit; yes, some should.”
As Brady transitions into his next chapter, preparing to join the Fox broadcast booth as an NFL commentator, his thoughts on the state of the game are likely to continue sparking conversation. Brady, who signed a 10-year, $375 million deal with Fox, is expected to bring the same depth of insight and understanding to his commentary as he did to his illustrious playing career. His reflections on the development—or lack thereof—of rookie quarterbacks offer a glimpse into the challenges facing the next generation of NFL stars.
