In Pittsburgh, the debate over the Steelers’ quarterback situation has taken center stage, dominating headlines and conversations among fans and analysts alike. For months, the discussion has revolved around veteran quarterback Russell Wilson and the team’s current starter, Justin Fields. With Wilson sidelined by a calf injury since before the start of the regular season, Fields has stepped into the starting role and led the Steelers to a respectable 4-2 record.
Fields, who had previously struggled to find consistency in his career, has shown flashes of his potential with the Steelers. In his time as the starter, he has thrown for five touchdowns and rushed for five more, injecting some excitement into the offense. His dual-threat ability has provided a spark, and there is growing sentiment that his rejuvenation could help the Steelers sustain their momentum.
However, as Russell Wilson inches closer to full health, the question of who should start moving forward has become increasingly pressing. Many expected Wilson to assume the starting role as soon as he was cleared to play, given his experience and the Steelers’ investment in him. But reports suggest that not everyone within the organization is enthusiastic about the idea of benching Fields in favor of Wilson.
According to Sports Illustrated’s Albert Breer, who discussed the situation on The Rich Eisen Show, head coach Mike Tomlin has yet to make a final decision about who will start once Wilson is fully healthy. “This is a decision that has not been made yet,” Breer said. “I know some people there that feel like Tomlin is gonna take this thing to the end of the week and really take a hard look at it.”
RELATED: Justin Fields Shares Candid Thoughts on Potentially Losing Starting QB Role
While Tomlin is known for his methodical approach and taking his time with big decisions, the internal debate seems to stem from concerns about how each quarterback’s style impacts the offense. Fields, with his mobility and ability to extend plays, has opened up new possibilities for the Steelers’ offense, allowing them to run a more dynamic scheme. On the other hand, Wilson, though a proven winner, has dealt with injuries and inconsistencies in recent seasons, leading some to wonder if he would limit the team’s potential upon his return.
“There are a ton of people in that place right now that feel like Russell Wilson would limit them on offense in a way that Justin Fields does not, which I think is a big part of the reason why so many people there just wish that Tomlin would stick with Fields,” Breer explained.
The Steelers are set to face the New York Jets in this week’s edition of Sunday Night Football, and all eyes will be on Tomlin’s decision.
While Wilson’s experience and past success make him a logical choice for many, Fields’ recent performances have made a compelling case for him to remain the starter. The internal divide within the Steelers organization reflects this tension, as some believe sticking with the hot hand in Fields gives the team a better chance to keep winning, while others see Wilson’s return as a key to unlocking their full potential.
Regardless of Tomlin’s eventual decision, the quarterback controversy in Pittsburgh is sure to continue fueling debates among fans, analysts, and even members of the Steelers organization. With a promising season on the line and two talented but very different quarterbacks in the mix, Tomlin’s choice could have significant implications for the team’s trajectory.
For now, it remains to be seen whether Wilson will reclaim his spot or if Fields will get an extended opportunity to lead the team deeper into the season.
