The Indianapolis Colts are in turmoil, and it seems that both current and former players are increasingly vocal about their dissatisfaction with what’s happening behind the scenes. As the Colts’ season continues to spiral downward, frustrations are mounting not just among the fan base but within the team itself.
Days after Colts defensive back Kenny Moore openly criticized the team for showing a lack of effort and urgency, former Colts punter and current ESPN analyst Pat McAfee weighed in with his own blunt assessment of the franchise’s struggles.
McAfee’s comments come amid a season where the Colts have struggled to maintain consistency, leaving fans and players alike questioning the culture and direction of the organization.
McAfee, who has never been one to shy away from sharing his opinions, had previously been critical of the Colts’ young quarterback Anthony Richardson. The criticism stemmed from an incident during the Colts’ October 27th loss to the Houston Texans, when Richardson opted to tap out of a drive, a move that McAfee called out as a lack of leadership.
However, on a recent episode of “The Pat McAfee Show,” McAfee took a different tone, issuing an apology to Richardson and expressing some regret over how harshly he had judged the young signal-caller.
“AR, I apologize for being so loud about you tapping out,” McAfee said during the episode. “It’s not good to have that happen for your team, but now I’m starting to think, did anybody—has anybody told AR how he’s supposed to be? Has anyone actually shown him the ropes? He’s got nobody telling him how to operate in that building.”
In his apology, McAfee pointed to a larger issue within the Colts organization, suggesting that Richardson might not be receiving the proper guidance and mentorship necessary for a young quarterback in the NFL.
The apology wasn’t just directed at Richardson but also served as a pointed critique of the Colts’ internal culture, which McAfee described as lacking the professionalism and leadership needed to foster young talent.
RELATED: Vikings Coach Explains Why He Gave Viral Encouragement to Colts’ Anthony Richardson
McAfee didn’t stop there. He continued to blast the Colts’ culture, pointing out systemic issues that have plagued the team throughout the season. He called for sweeping changes, taking aim at the leadership and suggesting that those in charge had failed both the players and the organization as a whole.
“Get ‘em all and get the f— out. Pay off all their contracts, too. Congrats, you robbed us. You stole from us,” McAfee said, his frustration palpable. “This group got us the No. 4 overall pick. This group has been through so much. This group has had to deal now with a bunch of different quarterbacks too, so this group probably feels a little bit like, ‘This is our NFL experience?’”
McAfee’s comments highlight a sentiment that has been echoed by others around the team: a feeling that the Colts are lacking direction, accountability, and stability. The revolving door of quarterbacks and inconsistent performances have left players disillusioned, questioning if this is the reality of their NFL careers.
The Colts, now sitting at 4-6, are coming off a disappointing 30-20 loss to the Buffalo Bills, a game that saw veteran quarterback Joe Flacco throw three interceptions in his second outing as the team’s starter. Despite the poor performance, head coach Shane Steichen indicated that Flacco will remain the starting quarterback for the remainder of the season.
The decision has been met with mixed reactions, as many fans and analysts are skeptical about whether Flacco is the right answer for a struggling offense.
For a team that was once filled with promise, the Colts have seen their aspirations unravel as they continue to lose games and battle internal discord. The current state of the franchise has led to increased scrutiny from both media and former players, and McAfee’s harsh words reflect a growing consensus that major changes are needed within the organization.
With Anthony Richardson, the Colts have a young, talented quarterback who has the potential to be the face of the franchise.
However, as McAfee pointed out, it’s crucial for the organization to surround him with the right leadership and support system to ensure his development. The lack of guidance and professional culture could end up stunting Richardson’s growth, which would be a significant setback for a team desperately in need of a long-term solution at quarterback.
As the Colts look ahead to the rest of the season, the focus now shifts to how they can rebuild not just their roster, but also the culture and identity of the franchise.
Whether or not drastic changes are made remains to be seen, but the calls for accountability are growing louder, and the pressure is on the Colts’ front office to prove that they are capable of steering the team in the right direction.
The remainder of the season will likely be a critical test for both the players and the coaching staff as they attempt to salvage what’s left of a disappointing campaign.
