Both the Mannings (Peyton and Eli) and the Kelces (Travis and Jason) have become household names in both the NFL world and pop culture, captivating fans with their unique personalities and contributions to the sport. While Travis Kelce remains the only one still playing professional football, his brother Jason has made a successful transition into the media world as an ESPN analyst. Together, they co-host their popular New Heights podcast, offering insights and humor that have made them fan favorites.
On the other side, the Manning brothers—Peyton and Eli—continue to entertain fans through their ManningCast, a Monday Night Football broadcast that has gained a massive following in recent years. Despite being retired from the NFL, the Mannings’ impact on the sport is undeniable, and their humor and dynamic brotherly banter keep them relevant both on and off the field. As the first family of quarterbacking, they remain a constant presence in football.
With both brotherly duos dominating the media landscape, it raises the question: which set of siblings do fans prefer? According to a recent informal X/Twitter poll conducted by OutKick’s Mike Gunzelman of The Gunz Show, the Mannings seem to have a clear edge over the Kelces in the public eye.
RELATED: NFL Fans Frustrated by Alleged Bias in ‘Monday Night Football’ Broadcast
The poll, which attracted over 4,300 votes, showed that a staggering 92.5% of respondents favored Peyton and Eli over Travis and Jason.
Gunzelman suggested that some of the possible backlash toward the Kelce brothers, especially Travis, might stem from oversaturation.
Travis, in particular, has been all over the media lately. He’s featured in numerous commercials, preparing for his acting debut, and of course, his every move is being closely followed due to his high-profile relationship with pop star Taylor Swift. In addition to all of this, he co-hosts New Heights with Jason, further adding to his media presence.
This level of exposure may be wearing on some fans, as the constant focus on Travis has reached a point where some might feel it’s overwhelming. While Jason shares the spotlight with him, it’s Travis who often takes center stage.
In contrast, the Mannings, though still very visible, seem to manage a more balanced presence. Their ManningCast remains popular without dominating headlines or commercials to the same extent as Travis and Jason’s ventures. Peyton and Eli’s roles feel more like a steady, familiar part of the NFL landscape rather than a media blitz.
Of course, it’s worth considering that this poll is an informal one, and with only 4,300 votes, it may not reflect the broader opinions of the NFL fanbase as a whole. Still, it does suggest that for some fans, the nostalgia and low-key presence of the Manning brothers win out over the more saturated media appearances of the Kelce brothers.
Whether this is just a small sample of opinions or a growing sentiment remains to be seen, but for now, it appears the Manning brothers are still the fan favorites in the battle of NFL siblings.
