Joe Burrow’s 2024 season has been nothing short of spectacular, but the Cincinnati Bengals quarterback finds himself at the center of a divisive debate as the regular season comes to a close. With MVP talk swirling and the Bengals fighting for a playoff spot, opinions on Burrow’s performance have ranged from high praise to sharp criticism.
The latest take, courtesy of Fox Sports’ James Jones, claims that it’s Burrow himself who has “wasted” his own season.
Burrow’s Season in Context
Burrow entered the final week of the season with an impressive resume, despite Cincinnati’s rollercoaster campaign. The Bengals, who were 4-8 just a month ago, have clawed their way back into the playoff conversation thanks to a four-game winning streak. Burrow’s numbers have been stellar, keeping him in the MVP conversation even as the team’s record has fluctuated. However, with a playoff berth still uncertain, the spotlight on Burrow has only intensified.
The Polarizing Debate
The narrative around Burrow’s season has been anything but consistent. In December, Shannon Sharpe criticized Burrow for Cincinnati’s struggles, arguing that the quarterback deserved some blame for the Bengals’ 4-8 record. Just weeks later, Troy Aikman declared during a Monday Night Football broadcast that Burrow would get his vote for NFL MVP.
These wildly different opinions highlight the unusual circumstances of Burrow’s season—a statistical masterpiece overshadowed by team struggles.
Now, James Jones has taken the debate in an unexpected direction. Speaking on The Facility, Jones argued that Burrow has “wasted” his own season, a claim that even his fellow analyst Chase Daniel questioned in disbelief.
RELATED: Joe Burrow Shares Three-Word Take on NFL MVP Odds
The Case Against Burrow
Jones’ argument hinges on the idea that Burrow hasn’t delivered in every clutch moment. While Burrow’s brilliance has been undeniable, he’s made a few costly mistakes in key games, including late-game interceptions and missed opportunities.
According to Jones, these moments have undermined what could have been an even more extraordinary season.
“There’s no denying his talent or his numbers,” Jones said. “But if we’re holding Burrow to the highest standard—and we should be—then we have to hold him accountable for the games where he didn’t come through.”
A Higher Standard?
While Jones’ take is certainly unique, it raises questions about the standards we set for elite athletes. Burrow has thrown for over 4,000 yards, with a touchdown-to-interception ratio that ranks among the league’s best. He’s been the engine of a Bengals team that has surged back into contention, despite a defense that has been among the league’s worst.
Critics of Jones’ argument point out that if Burrow is being judged so harshly, then what metric should be used to evaluate less accomplished players? By Jones’ logic, if Burrow’s remarkable season is deemed a waste, then almost every other quarterback would fall short of even basic expectations.
The Bigger Picture
The debate around Burrow’s season underscores the immense pressure placed on franchise quarterbacks. As the leader of the Bengals, Burrow is expected to elevate his team, even when other areas—like Cincinnati’s porous defense—fall short. While it’s true that Burrow hasn’t been perfect, his overall performance has been nothing short of MVP-caliber.
If Cincinnati misses the playoffs, it will likely be due to defensive failures rather than Burrow’s shortcomings. Yet, as the face of the franchise, Burrow will inevitably bear the brunt of the criticism.
A Historic Season Regardless
Whether or not the Bengals make the postseason, Burrow’s 2024 campaign will be remembered as one of the best individual seasons in franchise history. His ability to consistently deliver despite injuries to key players and a struggling defense speaks volumes about his talent and leadership.
As the Bengals prepare for their season finale, Burrow has the opportunity to silence critics and add another chapter to what has already been an incredible season.
Regardless of the outcome, one thing is clear: Burrow’s performance has set a standard that most quarterbacks can only aspire to, even if some believe he hasn’t reached his own potential.
