Retired NFL legend JJ Watt didn’t hold back on Saturday when criticizing the league for fining Kansas City Chiefs running back Isiah Pacheco a staggering $45,000 for a play deemed to involve unnecessary roughness. Watt, a five-time All-Pro defensive end, voiced his frustration on social media, calling the decision baffling and highlighting what he sees as an ongoing issue with the NFL’s disciplinary process.
The Play in Question
The incident occurred during the Chiefs’ narrow 19-17 victory over the Los Angeles Chargers. Late in the game, with the Chiefs facing 1st-and-14 from their own 5-yard line, quarterback Patrick Mahomes checked down a pass to Pacheco. The second-year running back sprinted toward the sideline and lowered his shoulder into Chargers cornerback Kristian Fulton before stepping out of bounds.
Despite no flag being thrown during the game, the league later determined that Pacheco had violated the rule prohibiting players from lowering their helmets to initiate contact. As a result, Pacheco was slapped with the hefty fine.
JJ Watt’s Reaction
Watt, now retired but still an influential voice in the football community, took to X (formerly Twitter) to express his disbelief at the fine, mocking the NFL’s decision with a sarcastic post.
“‘We’d like to pay you to play football,’” Watt began. “Plays football. Actually, we’re going to take some of that money back.’ For what? ‘Playing football.’”
Watt’s post captured the sentiment of many fans and players who feel that the league’s enforcement of safety rules can often be arbitrary and counterproductive.
RELATED: Boomer Esiason Unleashes on Mark Gastineau: ‘Dirty, Cheap-Shot Player’
A Pattern of Controversial Fines
This isn’t the first time Watt has spoken out about the NFL’s disciplinary actions. Since retiring after the 2022 season, Watt has frequently shared his thoughts on controversial league policies and decisions. He’s been especially critical when it comes to fines that penalize players for what many consider routine football plays.
Watt’s personal experiences may also play a role in his outspoken stance. He previously defended his brother, Pittsburgh Steelers linebacker TJ Watt, after the NFL fined him for a harmless joke during a game. The elder Watt has since made it a point to highlight what he perceives as inconsistencies in the league’s disciplinary system.
Fan and Player Backlash
Watt’s criticism resonated with fans and current players alike. Many echoed his sentiment, questioning how the league can justify such a substantial fine for a play that seemed like a textbook example of football physicality.
“Are we playing football or not?” one fan commented on Watt’s post. “This is ridiculous.”
Another fan added: “If that’s a $45K fine, we might as well switch to flag football.”
Even current and former players chimed in, expressing their frustration with the league’s rules on helmet contact, which they argue are often unclear and inconsistently enforced.
Balancing Safety and Football’s Nature
The NFL’s emphasis on player safety has led to the implementation of stricter rules regarding helmet usage, hits to the head, and other forms of contact. While these measures aim to reduce injuries, particularly concussions, they’ve sparked debate about whether the league is compromising the essence of the sport.
For many, including Watt, Pacheco’s play was an example of a running back doing his job—lowering his shoulder to gain extra yards and protect himself while going out of bounds. The lack of a flag during the game only adds to the confusion surrounding the fine.
The Bigger Picture
This incident raises questions about how the NFL enforces its rules and communicates with players. Critics argue that hefty fines for routine plays not only hurt players financially but also create a sense of uncertainty about what is and isn’t allowed on the field.
As one of the NFL’s most respected voices, Watt’s criticism carries weight. His comments highlight a growing concern among players and fans that the league’s rules are becoming increasingly detached from the physical nature of football.
What’s Next?
For Isiah Pacheco, the fine serves as an unwelcome reminder of the challenges players face in navigating the league’s evolving safety protocols. Meanwhile, for JJ Watt and others in the football community, the debate over the balance between safety and the sport’s inherent physicality is far from over.
The NFL has yet to respond to the backlash, but as the conversation continues, it’s clear that the issue of fines and disciplinary consistency remains a contentious topic in the league. Watt, as always, is unafraid to keep the spotlight on it.
