Aaron Hernandez’s life story is a tragic and complex one, marked by a meteoric rise in the NFL and an equally shocking fall from grace. As a standout college football player, Hernandez seemed destined for stardom when he joined the New England Patriots, playing under the legendary duo of head coach Bill Belichick and quarterback Tom Brady.
But beneath his athletic success lurked deeper, darker issues, leading to his involvement in a first-degree murder case that abruptly ended his career and landed him in prison.
This haunting tale was explored with great detail in Netflix’s documentary Killer Inside: The Mind of Aaron Hernandez, which was widely praised for its in-depth analysis of Hernandez’s troubled psyche and unraveling life. Hoping to capitalize on the success of that project, FX selected Hernandez as the subject of its American Sports Story series.
However, while the series garnered decent initial ratings, it has drawn significant criticism from sports fans who have taken issue with several glaring inaccuracies and questionable portrayals.
One of the most glaring missteps, according to fans, is the portrayal of Patriots head coach Bill Belichick. Actor Norbert Leo Butz steps into the role of the famously stoic and no-nonsense coach, but viewers have been quick to point out that his attempt to capture Belichick’s famously deadpan demeanor falls short. Instead of embodying the composed, calculating presence that has defined Belichick for decades, Butz’s portrayal has been described as overly stiff and inauthentic, missing the subtlety of the real Belichick’s personality.
RELATED: Bounty Video Surfaces Of Fan Asking Aaron Hernandez How Much ‘A Hit On Him Is Worth’
The series also fumbles in its depiction of Patriots owner Robert Kraft, with fans noting that the characterization feels off, contributing to the show’s overall struggles to capture the essence of key NFL figures involved in Hernandez’s career. While some level of artistic license is expected in a dramatized series, these portrayals have left viewers disappointed by their lack of nuance and depth.
But even more frustrating for sports enthusiasts are the numerous factual inaccuracies and blunders when it comes to the basic football elements of the show. A particularly egregious error involves a draft board scene where Aaron Hernandez is listed as a “DB” (defensive back), when he famously played tight end (TE) throughout his college and professional career. This kind of mistake, while minor to some, is a significant oversight for anyone familiar with Hernandez’s football legacy.
Other baffling details include the profile card of Erik Cook, an offensive lineman, being displayed with stats related to pass-rushing and receiving—skills completely unrelated to his position. These types of errors may seem small in the grand scheme of storytelling, but they reflect a lack of attention to detail that has left fans of both football and true crime feeling let down.
For a series intended to shed light on one of the most shocking and tragic figures in recent sports history, these mistakes make it hard for viewers to remain immersed in the narrative. What could have been an opportunity to further explore the complexities of Hernandez’s life and the culture of professional sports is instead marred by avoidable errors.
While some leniency is typically given to the performances of actors portraying well-known figures, especially when those figures are as notoriously reserved as Bill Belichick, the repeated missteps in basic football facts suggest a lack of respect for the source material. Fans expect a certain level of accuracy, especially when it comes to details that are easily verifiable.
In the end, FX’s American Sports Story series on Aaron Hernandez, despite its promising premise and intriguing subject, has struggled to live up to expectations.
The errors and questionable portrayals have sparked frustration among viewers, leaving many wondering how such an infamous story could be mishandled in such a fundamental way.
For now, sports fans remain unimpressed, hoping for more from future episodes, but for many, the damage has already been done.
