Arizona Cardinals quarterback Kyler Murray had an unexpected moment of anonymity when he was mistaken for just another regular guy by a tourist while grabbing pizza at a famous spot in New York City.
In a video shared by Murray’s social media manager, Emma Tani, the 27-year-old quarterback can be seen casually chatting with a stranger outside Joe’s Pizza, one of the city’s iconic pizza joints. Murray, standing by an outdoor table, was giving his own review of the popular pizza.
“What you think, bro?” Murray asked the man standing next to him as they both enjoyed their slices. The man, seemingly unaware of Murray’s NFL fame, replied nonchalantly, “Not bad.” When Murray inquired about what kind of pizza the man ordered, he responded, “One pepperoni one, and one normal one.”
Things took a slightly awkward turn when it became apparent that the man, who introduced himself as Surya, did not recognize Murray as an NFL star.
Rather than feeling uncomfortable, Murray seemed to relish the moment of being treated just like anyone else—a rarity for someone of his caliber. Their exchange continued to have a relaxed, down-to-earth vibe, a refreshing break from the limelight that Murray usually faces.
RELATED: Kyler Murray Shuts Down ‘Trolls’ by Turning ‘Call of Duty’ Memes Into Endorsement Deal
Surya revealed that he was visiting from Switzerland, and the two strangers chatted as they ate their slices. When it came time to share names, Murray simply said his name was Kyler, while Surya helped him with the spelling of his own name.
The candid conversation unfolded naturally, as if they were just two locals enjoying a casual day in New York.
They also continued to discuss their thoughts on the pizza, with Murray giving his critique. “I need some ranch,” he remarked, explaining that the slice was a bit too saucy for his liking. Surya agreed, adding that the pizza was “a bit too sweet.” Murray even commented on the crust, saying, “The bread ain’t breading,” jokingly critiquing the texture.
Curious about Murray’s activities, Surya asked, “So, you guys go around testing different pizzas or just this one?” Still unaware of who he was talking to, Surya seemed genuinely interested in the supposed pizza tour Murray was on.
“Nah, just enjoying New York,” Murray replied, downplaying any notion of being on an official pizza quest. He clearly enjoyed the normalcy of the interaction, staying low-key and simply blending into the bustling city around him.
Kyler Murray’s unexpected moment of anonymity came as a rare escape from his high-profile career. As a star quarterback, Murray is used to making headlines, not only for his prowess on the field but also for his charismatic personality.
This season, Murray has completed 191 of 276 passes for 2,058 yards and 12 touchdowns, leading the Cardinals to an impressive 6-4 record, which currently places them first in the NFC West.
While Murray is used to the pressures and expectations that come with leading an NFL team, his candid interaction at Joe’s Pizza showed a different side of him—one that enjoys the simple pleasure of grabbing a slice and having an unassuming conversation with a stranger.
It was a wholesome moment that many fans found endearing, showing that even high-profile athletes like Murray appreciate the little things in life, like a slice of pizza and a genuine conversation with a tourist from Switzerland.
