Jerod Mayo’s tenure as head coach of the New England Patriots ended abruptly this week after just one season, and a new report sheds light on some of the incidents that may have contributed to the surprising decision.
Chad Graff of The Athletic published an in-depth story on Wednesday detailing Mayo’s struggles transitioning from defensive assistant to head coach, highlighting moments that reportedly raised eyebrows among players, staff, and ownership.
A Troubling Flight Incident
One particularly notable incident occurred during the Patriots’ flight back to Massachusetts after a Week 15 loss to the Arizona Cardinals. According to Graff, Mayo exhibited behavior that some felt was more in line with a player than a head coach.
After the team’s 30-17 defeat, Mayo left his seat near the front of the plane, where coaches traditionally sit and review game film, and went to the back to play cards with players. Other members of the coaching staff were busy analyzing game footage at the time.
“Look, there are a lot of ways to do the job,” a source on the flight told Graff. “It’s not that Jerod’s was definitely wrong. But I can’t say I’ve seen that before.”
The optics of the incident reportedly didn’t sit well with some in the organization, especially considering the team’s ongoing struggles during a disappointing season.
RELATED: Patriots Star Jahlani Tavai Criticizes Fans in Shocking Outburst
Leadership and Discipline Issues
Mayo, a former Patriots linebacker and defensive captain, seemed to struggle with balancing his close relationships with players and the authority required of a head coach. According to Graff, Mayo made a conscious effort to distinguish himself from Bill Belichick’s strict coaching style. However, this approach may have backfired in some situations, leading to questions about his ability to enforce discipline.
One glaring example occurred in Week 17, when Mayo publicly stated that running back Rhamondre Stevenson would not start due to ball security issues. Despite this announcement, Stevenson started the game, creating confusion and undermining Mayo’s authority. Graff noted this was just one of several instances where Mayo appeared to struggle with discipline and accountability.
The Cardinals Game: A Turning Point
The Week 15 loss to Arizona was reportedly a pivotal moment for Mayo’s tenure. During the game, Mayo openly criticized his offensive coordinator, a move that many within the organization saw as unprofessional. The loss was further marred by a viral video of team owners Robert and Jonathan Kraft looking visibly frustrated and disgusted in the owner’s box.
Mayo’s decision to play cards on the flight after such a disastrous performance likely compounded concerns about his leadership style. For a franchise known for its emphasis on preparation and discipline, the optics of the situation were damaging.
Mayo’s Vision and Legacy
Mayo’s attempt to carve out a coaching identity distinct from Belichick’s was ambitious but ultimately fraught with challenges. While he earned respect as a player and assistant coach, the shift to head coach brought with it expectations he struggled to meet.
Graff’s report suggests that Mayo’s focus on being a players’ coach may have undermined his ability to command respect and make tough decisions when needed.
The Fallout
Ownership’s decision to part ways with Mayo reflects a broader frustration with the team’s performance and culture in recent years. The Patriots, once the NFL’s gold standard, have struggled to maintain their dominance following Tom Brady’s departure and are now searching for their third head coach in four years.
Mayo’s firing highlights the challenges of transitioning from a beloved player to a head coach tasked with managing former peers. While Mayo’s leadership style resonated with some, the lack of discipline and strategic missteps proved too significant to ignore.
What’s Next for the Patriots?
The Patriots now face the daunting task of finding a new head coach who can reinvigorate the team and restore its winning culture. For Mayo, the experience serves as a tough but valuable lesson in the complexities of leadership at the highest level.
Though his time as head coach was short-lived, Mayo remains a respected figure in the Patriots organization and the NFL.
Whether he returns to coaching or pursues another path, his legacy as a player and leader will continue to be part of the Patriots’ storied history.
