Over the years, former FS1 personality Skip Bayless has been an unwavering advocate for Tom Brady, consistently labeling him as the greatest football player of all time. However, when it comes to Brady’s post-retirement foray into broadcasting as an NFL analyst for Fox, Bayless’s opinion is far less favorable. In fact, it would be an understatement to say that Bayless hasn’t been a fan of Brady’s performance in the broadcast booth.
Brady’s transition from the field to the booth was always going to be heavily scrutinized. The seven-time Super Bowl champion was instantly thrust into a high-profile role on Fox’s top broadcast team, and it hasn’t come as naturally to him as his prowess on the football field. Brady has openly admitted that he’s still figuring out what NFL audiences want from him as an analyst, and his broadcast work so far has received mixed reviews.
For Bayless, who has spent years championing Brady as a quarterback, the disappointment has been especially pronounced. On the Monday episode of his podcast, “The Skip Bayless Show,” Bayless didn’t hold back in expressing his dissatisfaction with Brady’s work as a commentator.
“Alright, good news, Sunday’s Cowboys game is on CBS, not on Fox,” Bayless said. “So we get Tony Romo instead of Tom Brady. As I have said 12 trillion times, Tom Brady was the greatest NFL player ever by far. But as a TV analyst, he’s nothing but Daniel Jones. I’m sorry, but Tom Brady drove me nuts yesterday during the Detroit-Green Bay game with his endless, giddy, captain-obvious blabber.”
Bayless went on to elaborate, criticizing Brady for what he called “annoyingly obvious” commentary. “He just talks and talks and talks some more about what is so clichédly obvious. So annoyingly obvious, so Patriots-Brady talking to the media obvious. So eager to be nice guy Tom obvious. So little insight, so many words. So many close-ups. ‘Hi, I’m Tom Brady.’ Yeah, we know, unfortunately, we know, Tom,” Bayless vented.
Bayless’s harsh critique reflects a sentiment that others in the sports media industry have echoed as well. The primary complaint about Brady’s on-air performance has been his inability to effectively convey the depth of knowledge he possesses about the game to the viewers at home.
Many believe that while Brady undoubtedly has a wealth of football insight, he has struggled to translate that into compelling television commentary.
RELATED: Luxury Car Donated by Tom Brady to High School Disappears After $367,000 Raffle
The challenge of making the leap from a legendary NFL career to a successful broadcasting career isn’t unique to Brady. Drew Brees, another Hall of Fame quarterback, faced similar struggles during his brief stint as a broadcaster with NBC. Brees’s transition didn’t last long, as he ultimately parted ways with the network after a lackluster tenure. Brady, it seems, may also be finding out that excellence on the field doesn’t automatically equate to excellence in the booth.
Fox, of course, had high hopes when they signed Brady to a massive deal to join their broadcast team. The expectation was that Brady’s magnetic personality and his unparalleled experience would make him a natural fit as a commentator.
But thus far, it appears that Brady has yet to find his stride. His commentary has been criticized for lacking the depth and spontaneity that viewers have come to appreciate from other analysts like Tony Romo, who has become a fan favorite for his insightful and energetic breakdowns of plays.
For Bayless, who has been one of Brady’s staunchest defenders throughout his playing career, the criticism is notable. Bayless’s disappointment suggests that Brady’s journey as a broadcaster is far from over, and he still has a long way to go if he wants to live up to the expectations set by both Fox and the fans.
Being a quarterback and being a broadcaster require different skill sets—one relies on instinct and physical prowess, while the other demands an ability to articulate, entertain, and educate in real-time.
Whether Brady can eventually grow into the role that Fox envisioned for him remains to be seen. Some fans are willing to give him the benefit of the doubt, acknowledging that even the greatest athletes need time to adjust to new challenges.
However, for now, critics like Bayless are making it clear that the learning curve for Brady is steeper than anticipated, and his future in the booth is anything but guaranteed.
Until he finds a way to translate his on-field genius into the broadcast booth, the GOAT of the gridiron may have to deal with being just another rookie when it comes to commentary.
