Miami Dolphins quarterback Tua Tagovailoa has officially cleared the NFL’s concussion protocol and is set to make his return to the field this Sunday against the Arizona Cardinals. Tagovailoa’s comeback comes after a season marked by another concussion, adding to a concerning history of head injuries.
Despite this, the quarterback recently told reporters that he has no plans to wear a Guardian Cap—a helmet add-on designed to reduce head trauma—sparking mixed reactions from fans and analysts alike.
The Guardian Cap, a padded cover placed over the helmet, aims to minimize the force of impacts and lessen the risk of concussions.
Given Tagovailoa’s history, some questioned why he would opt out of wearing it. However, neuroscientist Chris Nowinski offered a different perspective, supporting Tagovailoa’s decision. “Give Tua Tagovailoa a break on the Guardian Cap,” Nowinski wrote in a post on X. “All 3 of his 2022 concussions were from falling back & his head striking the ground. Adding 14 ounces to his helmet would make head-to-ground impacts even more likely. Better off never hitting the ground vs. hitting it with a pad.”
RELATED: Tua Tagovailoa on Taking Risks: ‘I’m Willing to Play the Odds’
Nowinski’s argument highlights the nuanced role of the Guardian Cap.
While it can be beneficial, especially for collisions, Tagovailoa’s concussions have typically come from backward falls that cause his head to hit the ground—a scenario where the cap could potentially do more harm than good by increasing the weight and, therefore, the momentum of his head during a fall.
Nowinski’s support for Tagovailoa’s choice underscores the limitations of safety gear, which is often tailored to general scenarios rather than individual cases.
As Tagovailoa prepares for his return, fans are hopeful that his concussion struggles are behind him. The quarterback’s performance on Sunday will be closely watched, with many rooting for his success while staying mindful of the risks he faces.
His journey in managing head injuries will undoubtedly continue to be a topic of discussion as he navigates a season in which player safety remains a top priority.
